Max and Annie (Jason Bateman and Rachel McAdams) join their friends for game night at the home of Max's brother Brooks. Brooks (Kyle Chandler) orchestrates an elaborate set-up for a kidnapping, but he actually gets abducted by real kidnappers.
Brooks is wanted by a criminal known as The Bulgarian for selling a faberge egg containing a list of people in witness protection. The group finds the egg and delivers the list to the kidnappers, only to find out that they were set up by Max and Annie's weird neighbor Gary, who just wanted in on the game night. However, the real Bulgarian finds Brooks and takes him, leading Max and Annie to go rescue him and knock out the Bulgarian.
Three months later, Brooks is under house arrest, but he has a better relationship with Max, and Annie announces to Max that she is pregnant.