I Know What You Did Last Summer

The killer is Ben Willis (Muse Watson), NOT David Eagan. Ben Willis killed David Eagan (Jonathan Quint) right before Julie, Ray, Helen and Barry (Jennifer Love Hewitt, Freddie Prinze Jr., Sarah Michelle Gellar and Ryan Phillippe) hit him. Ben is a psychotic fisherman who had killed Egan (his daughter's boyfriend) after she died in a car accident, and now plans to kill the four kids who ran over him. The only survivors are Julie and Ray. Ben is (supposedly) killed at the end by Julie.
Thanks, Valentin P and Patay1792a!

(Links open in new window)
Read more about this film at The Internet Movie Database.

Buy it on VHS or DVD at Amazon.com.
Buy the soundtrack CD at Amazon.com.

Buy this poster at moviegoods.com