The Door in the Floor

Ted (Jeff Bridges) admits that he hired Eddie (Jon Foster) to seduce his wife Marion (Kim Basinger), so that Ted wouldn't feel guilty about cheating on her. He tells Eddie the story of how their sons were killed in a car accident. Marion leaves, unable to cope with her guilt, taking all the family photographs with her. Eddie goes back to his family, leaving Ted to raise his daughter alone. The implication is that Ted will keep sketching (and sleeping with) every woman on the island.
Thanks, Writtenbypatrick!