House of Wax
The house burns down, with both evil twin brothers Bo and Vincent (both Brian Van Holt) dead inside. Carly (Elisha Cuthbert) and her twin brother Nick (Chad Michael Murrary) are the only survivors, even though Carly had the end of her left index finger cut off. It turns out that Bo and Vincent had another brother, the Roadkill Driver (Damon Herriman).
(Links open in new window)
Read more about this film at The Internet Movie Database.