Finders Fee
(2001)

After an intense game of poker, Tepper (Erik Pallandino) wins the lottery ticket worth 6 million dollars.  Avery (James Earl Jones), the person who the winning ticket belonged to, is attacked by Quigley (Ryan Reynolds) with a wine bottle to the skull.

As it turns out, the winning numbers happen to be the date that his grandson was born.  Tepper chews out Quigley and decides to give Avery his ticket. 

As he is heading over to Carla's (Carly Pope) place to win her back, the real Avery shows up at the door.  The person we all thought was Avery (James Earl Jones) was in fact an imposter.

Thanks Brian C!